Hey i love your imagines by the way! I was wondering if you could do one where the reader has a bad past with angels so whenever she's around them she gets edgy and little scared. And she meets Castiel and Dean and Sam have to convince her it's okay.
Anonymous
Hi! Thank you so much for saying that! It means a lot to me. Here is the imagine you requested. I hope you enjoy it!
~~~~~~
“Hey, guys!” you called out, letting yourself into the motel room. “I spoke to the wife of that guy who was murdered.”
“Anything interesting?” Sam asked.
“Nothing that seemed to be of note. Who’s this?” you asked, finally noticing a man wearing a tan trench coat sitting on the small lounge. You were positive that you hadn’t seen him before in your two months of hunting with the Winchesters.
“Y/N, this is Cas. Cas, this is Y/N,” Dean introduced you.
“Hi,” you greeted him, sticking out your hand. Cas hesitated for a minute before shaking it.
“I’m Castiel.”
“Interesting name,” you said with a grin. “So how come I haven’t seen you around before?”
“I had business to take care of in Heaven,” Cas replied.
You froze. “What?”
“Cas is an angel,” Sam explained.
“Get away from me!” you cried, backing up in the corner of the room.
“I don’t understand. Have I in some way offended you?” Castiel asked, stepping towards you.
“Get away!” you repeated, your whole body now trembling.
Sam and Dean looked at each other in confusion.
“Ah, Cas, why don’t you give us a minute,” Dean suggested.
“As you wish,” Castiel replied, vanishing into thin air.
“Oh, God,” you said, sinking to the floor. You buried your face in your hands and tried to swallow the lump forming in your throat.
“Y/N?” You looked up to see Sam and Dean crouching beside you. “Do you want to tell us what’s wrong?” Sam continued.
“He’s an angel,” you choked out.
“We’ve noticed. What’s the big deal?” Dean asked in confusion.
“Do you know what they’ve done? There was a demon attack one day and my entire family, who was devoutly religious, was all killed! And just when the demon got to me, this angel appeared and killed it. Then it looked at me and spouted some crap about ‘collateral damage’ or something. And then it just disappeared! Just like that!” you burst out. “It didn’t matter that they were good people. To that angel, their deaths were 'for the greater good!’”
“Y/N, we’re so, so sorry. We had no idea about any of that. But trust me, Cas isn’t like that,” Sam told you.
“Damn right, he’s not,” Dean cut in. “Listen, Y/N, we’ve met other angels. And plenty of them were dicks. But Cas is different. You trust us, right?”
“Of course,” you whispered.
“Well, do you think we’d ever work with Cas if he was like that?” You shook your head.
“Do you think… I mean, would it be possible for you to call him back? So that I can meet him properly?” you asked hesitantly.
“Are you sure?” Sam questioned.
“I think so. Just…stick by me please.”
“Of course,” Sam smiled.
“Hey, Cas!” Dean called. The angel appeared in the centre of the room.
“You called?” he asked.
“Y/N wanted to meet you properly,” Dean explained. Castiel turned to you.
“Hello,” he said, making sure to keep his distance.
“Hi,” you replied shyly.
Castiel took a step closer. “I’m sorry if I have frightened you,” he said.
You were touched at how considerate he was being. The angel you’d met in the past never would’ve treated you with such kindness. It was this, more than anything else that the Winchesters could’ve told you, that convinced you to give Cas a chance.
“It’s okay. It wasn’t your fault. I’ve just had bad experiences with angels in the past,” you told him.
“I am sorry for that,” he said. “I shall endeavour to make sure your future experiences with angels are much better,” he finished with a smile, which you readily returned.
The exception, not the rule, you think.
~~~~~~
Thank you for reading! I just realised that this was my first imagine involving Cas, which I find pretty cool. Feedback is welcome and I’d love to get some more requests!
Please don’t repost without giving credit!